Ok, how do you measure current draw?
This is what I do:
Hook up the pedal with the input jack connected (this will complete the circuit).
Un-snap one of the battery terminals (doesn't matter whether -ve or positive) leaving the other still connected to the battery (this will now "open" the circuit).
Use DMM, one probe on the battery (the one that is not connected to the snap) and the other probe on the snap (which is not connected to the battery).
Current draw should be displayed on DMM.
Current draw should differ when you turn on/off the effect.
Voltage reading - in parallel
Current reading - in series
If you're certain all the steps that you took are correct, the only way to be certain that your DMM is busted, is cross check with a working DMM.
Hope that helps...