I should mention that I had just finished a Red Bull, so my hands were shakier than normal and I should have waited for that to subside. The problem began when I accidentally soldered one of the holes for R3. I got the resistor in there and soldered, but instead of reading near the 220 ohms it read about 134 or so even after desoldering and soldering it again. I then went back through the first two. R2, which read at a perfect 33k at first, now reads about 11k. R2 is right next to R3 where the problem began.
I've resoldered R2 and the results were the same. I then soldered in R4 to see if maybe I burned the board to the point that none of the resistors would read correctly.
My questions are: Can one "ruin" a board if the iron accidentally (from shaky hands) touches a spot that is not designated for soldering joints? If so, would resistors even show a value on a DMM if that were the case? Also, could the excessive heat from soldering the resistors in a few times have tampered with the resistance?
Unfortunately, I only ordered one of each resistor I needed so I can't try replacing them at the moment. So now I'm trying to figure out if I need to order a new PCB.