Page 1 of 1

Sound differences between LF353P and LF353N?

Posted: 25 Jun 2021, 04:00
by A1full
hi, does anyone know if there is difference between LF353p vs LF353n? sound different really? They tell me the LF353n has more gain... What should I look at in the data sheet?

Is there a post or a web, where they indicate the type of sound they deliver, the different and better known ics?

thanks

Re: CHIPS

Posted: 25 Jun 2021, 05:12
by FiveseveN
Texas Instruments say the -P indicates PDIP package and -N is for lead-free (NOPB). Fairchild/ON have -N for DIP and -M for SOIC.
They tell me the LF353n has more gain...
The point of an op amp is to have its gain set by external components (through feedback), so it's a strong sign that "they" don't know what they're talking about.
What should I look at in the data sheet?
The part where the suffixes are explained, i.e. page 1 of the TI datasheet, page 6 (second to last) of the ON one etc.
Is there a post or a web, where they indicate the type of sound they deliver, the different and better known ics?
IC means integrated circuit, yes? Op amps are only one type of integrated circuit commonly used in stompboxes. In fact we rather commonly (ab)use ICs in ways they were not designed for (CMOS inverters in "linear" regime, LM386 and even LM555 fuzzes etc.). So "known ics" covers a lot of ground, but more importantly the sound of an effect generally depends on the entire circuit, not just the one component.

Re: CHIPS

Posted: 25 Jun 2021, 15:36
by A1full
Thank you very much for your answer, there are things that I share others that I do not think are like that.
When you make a pedal, the operational one helps a lot to find the sound, an rc4558 is very different from a lm833, the sound obtained in each differs a lot.
In this case I received lf353n today and I can assure you that they work better than lf353p, the problem is that I can't know why.

Re: CHIPS

Posted: 25 Jun 2021, 15:41
by Jarno
For a start, because YOU know that you put in another opamp, it sounds different. I do think there are differences in "sound" from one opamp to another, which cannot be explained by looking at the characteristics in the datasheet, but they are marginal, unless you use an IC outside of it's intended use.

Re: CHIPS

Posted: 25 Jun 2021, 18:30
by CheapPedalCollector
I made a test circuit to listen to noise and gain of opamps, some can vary widely, others not so much. I think it depends on the manufacturer's level of QA tolerance specs.

Re: Sound differences between LF353P and LF353N?

Posted: 26 Jun 2021, 09:52
by The G
Different op amps could cause a certain circuit sound different. And probably a heap of another variables, too.
I'll rephrase what was already said. How relevant are these differences next to the differences in the circuits including the said op amps? How relevant are differences between IC packages (which is what the OP asked)? My guess is not much at all.
This could be (and was) tested in various ways. And first question I ask about a test is what was done to remove the human biases (which is why the blinded experiments were developed).